- Joined
- Oct 20, 2008
- Messages
- 3,346
No, no it's not. It helps no one. We're not speaking in code at all. Read back through the threads on common vs. scientific names or to a couple of choice posts in this thread. If you're just keeping a species or two & have no intention of breeding, fine. When you need details on a particular spider, good luck finding reasonable information via common name. Not so stunningly, many people here now that made this same claim when they first started in the hobby have made a 180 and have surprised themselves with how utterly easy it is to pick up on binomials. If you want to insist on calling your "tatarntulas" by their common names, you will necessarily catch a lot of flack by people that have put out the effort to learn this" foreign language". The vast majority of us here care not for what the person on the street or the "person at random" thinks about something they know nothing about. Common sense, as is said, is not all that common. Also, dog breeds are not of representative of any multiple species. Quite the contrary- they are highly manipulated physical characteristics of the same species. If you want to be taken seriously, please learn to "do as the Romans do, when in Rome".i was going to say this in my newly created thread "what species lay the most eggs" only because someone gave me crap about using "common names"...the same happened on the other forum that i posted the same question about egg sac size. my question was totally ignored, but insead im told to call them by their scientific names...
As far as the scientific names….here is my opinion about their usage. Thanks to all of you, that insist on using these extremely long and hard to pronounce names, the tatarntula & hobby is very unknown throughout the world.
Think about it, do dogs have strange scientific names? And if they do, how many people would be able to name the breeds off hand, or spell, or pronounce. Very few im sure. But look at how popular dogs are throughout the world, and how many people have pretty basic knowledge of most dog breeds. Or lets look at snakes, if you were to ask people at random, name 3 popular types of snakes. What would they say? Python, boa, anaconda, rattler, gartner? Or would they say some crazy scientific names, like regis, imperator, eunectes, crotalus, columbrid.
Twenty years ago, if you would have asked me what a tarantula was, I would have said a very big spider. While not having any clue, that there was close to 800 different tarantula species. If you asked ten people at random today, “name a type of tarantula” you’d be lucky if one person knew their was more than one type. Why is this? Its because you people don’t use the common names. Ive never heard anyone talk about common names of tarantulas, up until six months ago when I started to research the purchase of T's. To me and most others, a tarantula is just a tarantula. Just a big spider. Im sure if there common names were used more frequently in the past, I would have heard of all the different species years ago. “wow look! A Mexican red knee” or “o-my god, look how big that goliath bird eater is” do you really think the average person is going to want to memorize all these scientific names? “hey look, what a beautiful brachypelma smithi” or “hey look at this huge theraphosa blondi” and those are the easier ones to say. But see if any one has heard of the white collared tarantula, I doubt they’ll say “o you mean the eupalaestrus weijenberghi”
now if you went out on to the streets, and ask people to name a type of spider, what would they say? tarantula, black widow, daddy long leg? NOBODY is going to say the scientic name. why? its because its like speaking a foreign language.
Thanks to all you ignoring the common names, and insisting on trying to be all official with your scientific mumbo jumbo, I and so many others have missed out on a great hobby/pet.
And look, here I am trying to learn and gather data for other commoners (in my thread, about egg sac size), and what happens? “don’t use the common names, you should try and use the scientific names, WHY! so the hobby continues to stay a secret to the rest of the world. “here, we speak in code”…”we don’t use common words”…“get with the program!” its very irritating when i think about it. i mean dont get me wrong, its good to know the scientific names, but its more important to learn and spread the common names first!
I highly doubt that you "T collectors" could know all these excessively long scientific names, but not the short memorable common names that go with them. You people need to embrace the common names, for the prosperity of the hobby.