T. Domestica

@Ungoliant Here's a ventral pic, the quality sucks but I don't have a camera besides my phone. From what I found, both males and females of this species have the same shaped dark mark, making it difficult to sex them without a good macro lens? But I'm also not an expert at this.

@netherguard The ventral pic is for species identification in this case.

Where ranges overlap, a ventral image can help distinguish between Tegenaria domestica and Eratigena.

But given that yours is from Ohio, Tegenaria domestica is the most likely ID.